During Mobile Disrupt 2025, Counterpoint sat down with B-Stock’s VP of Mobility, Sean Cleland, to discuss the secondary smartphone market, its ever-volatile nature, and what trends the ecosystem is expected to face in H2 2025. The secondary market continues to outpace the new smartphone market YoY, and each year there are new hurdles the market needs to overcome to continue this prolific growth. There have been various new changes in 2024 and H1 2025 that the secondary market needs to address, such as AI, new form factors as foldables gain penetration, and ultimately macroeconomic factors that impact the market’s supply and demand. Emily Herbert, Senior Analyst at Counterpoint, and Sean Cleland discuss the impacts of tariffs, change in supply chains and consumer shifts in the secondary smartphone space.
The Interview
Key Takeaways from the Discussion:
Tariffs Increase Costs of New Devices, Causing Spillover into Used Market
• The retail price of new smartphones has increased due to tariffs on imported electronics, which has drawn consumers toward pre-owned and refurbished options.
• The secondary market benefits from strong demand as buyers look for affordable alternatives. Refurbishers have been able to prevent price increases in H1 2025, but an inventory replenishment may result in higher prices.
Supply Chain Disruptions and Component Squeeze
• The tariffs have increased costs of imported parts and components, especially from Asia. This has resulted in refurbishers facing thinner margins due to pricier repairs and replacements.
• Some companies consider reshoring or diversifying refurbishment operations to reduce tariff exposure.
Shift in Consumer Behavior & Device Longevity
• Consumers are delaying upgrades and holding on to devices longer, hoping to avoid tariff price uncertainty and also to get the most out of their devices before reselling.
Acceleration of Maturation and Innovation in the Secondary Market
• The secondary smartphone market is becoming more sophisticated and structured. Automated testing, better grading systems, and streamlined trade-in programs help manage costs and reduce ‘trust’ concerns that customers may have when looking to buy a used device.
Analyst Take
• How the secondary market will be affected by the tariffs announced in April 2025 will not be seen until H2 2025, as the new market will be the first to take a hit from the price shifts.
• Secondary device sales are still expected to climb, especially in emerging markets as consumers look for the most cost-effective way to get a high-quality device for the lowest cost.